Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
Tragicomedia en los finales de ajedrez
2016
Samuel Beckett's popular play Endgame, depicts a prison-like room with two windows that show a dead universe and a "corpsed world". Throughout his play, Beckett uses ideas, symbols, objects, and actions that reflect an ending. In Endgame the characters cannot choose; it seems that everything is coming to an end and they can do nothing about it; they have to accept it. The play's world is devoid of meaning, warmth, humor and all beautiful things. In most of his works Beckett shows that human faculties are deteriorating and Endgame is no exception. Hamm and Clov are not mobile; Hamm cannot stand and Clov just moves in a limited way. Nagg and Nell are confined in a dustbin totally without action and mobility. Hamm's chronicle is an unfinished one and one can generalize it to all Beckett's works as they avoid closure. In fact the play starts from the point where it's "nearly finished " and it ends the same.
Tragic features have traditionally been exported from tragedy to the novel. One of these is tragic fate, which explores the limitations of human agency by mightier forces. The nature of this fate has varied throughout tragic tradition, generally moving from metaphysical or theological to historical or contingent stances. This shows that the tragic adapts to reflect the peculiarities of the times; therefore, not only is the tragic still operative nowadays, but it conveys views intrinsically grounded on the context of the authors, serving both as a depiction and reaction for modern issues. Modern representations of tragic fate present some recurrent features. The dichotomy between human agency and fatalistic forces is blurred, triggering tensions that make heroes reconsider the roles they play in their lives. Fulfilled or frustrated anagnorises may then take place. This conflict also implies a reconsideration of perspectives: humanity gets overridden by social or cosmic forces that are beyond characters’ understanding. Nevertheless, they usually are well aware of destiny’s presence and they rationalize it by using ancient narratives. The tragic tone comes from the tension between the expectations created by these narratives, proven either false or unable to explain the whole picture. In this sense, modern tragic looks back at previous conceptualizations of fate: rather than deny destiny, it actualizes it and emphasizes its tragic dimension. In parallel, the texts deploy this fate by means of formal devices. I propose that authors emphasize internal coherence to evoke in the reader the feeling that all events are inevitably connected. As formal integrity is not necessarily connected with tragedy, it can help to express fate in the novel. Nevertheless, the expectations that it creates can be misleading, either by not being fulfilled or by being fulfilled in devious ways. The corpus to which I apply these ideas is composed of three novels: Zola’s La Curée, which serves to introduce the dynamics that will be found later, and two contemporary works from the 1990s, Murakami’s The Wind-up Bird Chronicle and Matute’s Olvidado Rey Gudú. This implies dealing with three apparently unconnected texts: the fact that the same pattern emerges in such different contexts to express tragic fate suggests that the phenomenon with which I am dealing may be more spread than expected and keep a close relation with the grounds of modernity, as it appears dissociated from specific traditions and restricted backgrounds. The pattern to which I am referring consists in confrontations between different conceptualizations of destiny: a first one is detected by the characters and creates in them expectations that are betrayed by the emergence of the second one, which appears as more ominous and threatening. The tension thus created constitutes the tragic tone of the novels. La Curée recreates the Greek myth of Phaedra, which serves to evoke a classical version of fate, linked with the goddess Venus and the passions she arouses; the appearance of such forces in a naturalist environment, which is driven by determinism, provokes the tragic conflict. In The Wind-up Bird Chronicle the hero conceptualizes the forces that act beyond his control as the destiny that helps the romance knight to fulfill his quest; however, the outcome of his adventure does not live up to his expectations, suggesting the presence of a more sinister, unknown fate which works at a cosmic instead of a human level. Finally, in Olvidado Rey Gudú characters conceive destiny as a performative act to justify their actions before others and construct for themselves a prospect of glory; this projects are nonetheless derailed by cosmic forces that impose oblivion over humankind. As a conclusion, I propose that this re-conceptualization of fate may serve as a response to the discourse on unrestricted freedom evoked by sentimental humanism and a certain brand of liberalism. As means of closure, I consider how tragic fate raises the questions of guilt and accountability.
PAJ: A Journal of Performance and Art, 2018
he story, which I must tell you presently, has not actually happened yet. But the certainty that it will happen is so crushing that I shall relate it to you in the past tense. This way, it will spare you the precious illusion that something might still be done about it. For this is not the case. You can start right away with your mourning and your sorrow. They were four. And they were to enact the last tragedy. The flag mast, the admiral ship of the theatre-that's what they were going to sink in one reckless, glaringly blinding performance. Tragedy's universal annihilation, nothing less was their aim.
Journal of Humanities Insights , 2022
This paper aims to unmask the sharp vestiges of Absurdity as an offshoot of Existentialism both through the form and content of the play, for which, a skull-like room devoid of any sign of life and hope has been designed. As a matter of fact, this research focuses on the imbroglio after the Second World War from which no exit door could be found and this overwhelming bog is mostly represented through the two characters who are called Hamm and Clov. In addition to that, the co-dependency between the Modern Men as an absurdist notion is represented through the bonding between Hamm and Clov; although Clov every now and then gets exhausted by giving services to Hamm, he supposes that if the bonding between them is torn, their existence will be at stake. It is worth mentioning that the cyclical pattern of the play as an embodiment of the cyclical stasis of human existence alongside the unconscionable repetitions in characters' dialogues which stands for the emptiness and meaninglessness of modern life will be discussed in detail. Apart from the absurdist features of Endgame which have been succinctly referred to, another underlying trait of this literary movement, namely the failure of language to help the characters communicate well and its pivotal role as a propeller towards their isolation and alienation will be scrutinized. Finally, an important question, which has made Endgame's attentive readers overly curious is to be answered in this research; the question is that 'are characters' actions in this play a representation of Existentialist philosophy or Absurdism?'
2019
In After Fukushima: The Equivalence of Catastrophes, Jean-Luc Nancy examines the nature of the Fukushima nuclear disaster through what he terms “the equivalence of catastrophes” involving “the complexity of interdependent systems (ecological or economic, sociopolitico-ideologic, technoscientific, cultural, logical.” In his viewpoint, “equivalence of catastrophes” is closely related to “finality itself – aiming, planning, and projecting a future in general.” He asserts that without emerging from finality itself, we cannot turn away from “the equivalence of catastrophes.” He perceives Fukushima nuclear disaster as a situation that demands us to emerge from “finality itself” and “work with other futures.” He suggests that we need to remain exposed to the “after” in “after Fukushima,” which he remarks as a rupture or suspense. An analysis of Samuel Beckett’s post-apocalyptic play, Endgame, aids in thinking about the notion “after.” It presents a vision of the world after a catastrophic ...
The Journal of Dramatic Theory and Criticism, 2002
For centuries western ....Titers and critics have viewed tragedy as central to their cultural tradition. For almost as long, they ha ve wondered whether tragedy has disappeared , and if so exac tly why it disappeared. Wagn er 's attem pt to revive tragic drama th rough opera wa s intended as a resp onse to the purported disappearance of tragedy as an art fonn; and Nietzsche 's you thful essa y The Birth of Tragedy (1872) is part ly an exploration of tragedy 's death and its supposed rebirth in Wagner 's artwork of the future, In the United States, Joseph Wood Krutch declared the death of tragedy in his boo k The Modern Temper in 1929, arguing, "we write no tragedies today, but we can still talk about the tragic spirit of which we would, perhaps , have no conception were it not for the" tragedies of previous centuries.' George Steiner's 196 1 study The Death oJ Tragedy demonstrates some of the ways in which western writers like Wagner and critics lik...
The unbearable pain of inertia ,the helplessness involved in understanding that there is no escape creates a sense of inevitability and also the absurdity of existence. Endgame releases our indeterminate suffering by giving us this realisation that existential prison-house is there for us to stay.
2009
As a whole, this work serves to illuminate the tragic as a fundamental human phenomenon and an objective fact that is distinct not only from comedy and irony but from other forms of calamity and modes of failure. I consider three distinct sources of philosophical knowledge on ...
Journal of Medieval and Early Modern Studies
The initial stimulation for this special issue was a recent book by the distinguished Anglican theologian and literary critic Rowan Williams, The Tragic Imagination (2016). This is an immensely ambitious, confident book with many suggestive directions and provocations, but we were particularly struck by two central strands. First: the production of a grand narrative concerning a literary form designated "the tragic imagination," which can be traced from the culture of ancient Greece to the theater of modern Britain. Second: the conviction that "the tragic imagination" is as compatible with Christianity as it is with the religion of Sophocles or with contemporary modes of atheism. The first strand raises some issues that any grand narrative must address. How can a story be told that spans many centuries involving profound social, cultural, and economic transformations, a story involving profound changes in the conception of what it is to be a human person, while attending to the minute particulars that constitute divergent and varying histories? Some of the problems encountered by grand narratives were recently addressed in the special issue produced in JMEMS responding to Brad S. Gregory's The Unintended Reformation: How a Religious Revolution Secularized Society (2012). 1 Is Williams, in his work, sufficiently attentive to the particularities of tragic form? For example, if one wants to talk about Milton and tragedy one may decide, as Williams does, to give a few pages to Samson Agonistes. 2 But Williams's discussion of Milton's extraordinary work is so lacking in attention to specificities that even the identity of speakers is ignored in the service of assimilating this awkward text into the critic's analytical plot. So it is no surprise that such a version of Samson Agonistes and tragedy is cut off from the text with which Milton chose to publish it, Paradise Regained. If one wants to make claims about Christianity and tragedy, it should seem odd to ignore Milton's juxtaposition of these two
Athens Epidaurus Catalogue , 2021
(trans. Konstandinos Tzikas)
Postmodern Openings, 2018
This article leads a phenomenological reading towards the dramaturgy of Samuel Beckett and more specifically his Endgame with recourse to the doctrine of Merleau-Ponty. By mapping out a drama that decentralizes subject-ivity, Beckett " s Endgame textualizes the subversion of the constancy of identity (" être-pour-soi ") of the modern man who holds a dichotomous look on subject and object in his dominating view on the world. From this perspective, Endgame exudes an atmosphere of existential Angst which peaks in a potential way of being that prevails in the hope for an authentic life but yet at the same time falls in a cosmic exile that emanates from man " s failure in his dominance over the world. Here, the examples of the Hegelian master-bondage concept and experimental psychology are felicitous reflections of this tragic relegation of man. Accordingly, registering the Pontian phenomenology of disembodiment delineates the characters of the Endgame as (in)human beings lost in a meaningless space that abandons all attempts to influence the progress of the mechanistic material world they live in. Nevertheless, this case study traces the humanistic resonance of man to bestow new methods of exploring Beckett " s " art of failure " as a relevant aesthetic reaction of the destabilized man in the modern world.
College Literature, 2015
In this paper we will study how the notions of cultural memory and trauma are represented through Samuel Beckett’s theater play Endgame. Endgame proposes a post-apocalyptical vision of the world and is therefore very interesting in the sense that it presents itself as a possible testimony of what happened and in what condition humanity is left. We will in a first time see how these concepts are interpreted and translated into the work itself and through its various characters. Further on we will see how Heidegger’s interview with Der Spiegel untitled Only a God Can Save Us meets many notions approached in Beckett’s work. Heidegger’s theoretical framework will help us to gain a deeper insight into the play, in order to interpret its complex and absurd aspects. The idea of technicity and Heidegger’s take on the tension engendered by the cold war will be of particular interest since we will see how they correlate with the situation developed in Endgame. In the end we will see how through the absurdity of Endgame we come to understand that it exemplifies the loss of faith in the ideals of humanism but also how it is a tragic testimony of the horrors witnessed through the 20th century. Finally we will come to see that Endgame can be seen as a drama cornerstone regarding post-modern trauma.
Literary Happy Endings, 2012
Despite virulent attacks and deep dissatisfaction expressed by critics and sometimes novelists themselves, be they modern or postmodern in their approach, throughout the twentiethcentury, happy endings have not necessarily completely deserted the contemporary novel but more often than not have evolved with their times. The aim of this paper is thus to point to ways in which happy endings still appear in the contemporary novel, with the world view and aesthetics entailed in their various transformations.
Philosophers have long argued over the nature of free-will; whether one is forced to enact a predetermined cosmic or biological mandate or whether one is free to truly determine their own destiny. Yet, regardless of the true state of external affairs, one can effectively live their life as if either proposition is correct. To internalize the notion of radical free will can be called existentialism, whereas the internalization of predeterminism labels one a fatalist. While it may be impossible to answer the ontological question of external free will, it is certainly possible to examine those lives who commit themselves to either form. Aside from the naturalists like Stephen Crane who trap their many Maggies in the bondage of biological happenstance, most modern fiction allows its characters the freedom to adopt an internalized stance on free will. The notion of existential responsibility weighs heavily in the pages of Julian Barnes’ novel The Sense of an Ending, with direct mention of Camus’ The Myth of Sisyphus included in the immortalized quote “suicide [is] the only true philosophical question” (Barnes 15). The previously stated separation between fatalism and existentialism is not cast as a dichotomy within this paper, but as a continuum upon which the individual fluctuates. When one loses a clear sense of their personal freedom he naturally gravitates towards fatalism, for the world then begins to act upon him instead of him upon it. Likewise, one necessarily overcomes fatalism to reach a state of personal responsibility, rejecting the world’s existential pressure and internalizing a distinct purpose. Barnes’ protagonist, the “average” Tony who only wants “life not to bother” him, rides the rail between a man condemned to fate and one who moves with internal purpose. Defying the natural progression assumed in the novel format, he peaks at the middle and declines into despair, discontent that his weak attempts at redemption and purpose fall short. He represents a realistic existential portrayal, one detached from the pristine perfection that an Absurd hero like Sisyphus embodies. While Camus asserts that “one must imagine Sisyphus happy,” that the eternal struggle against meaninglessness is enough in itself to fuel a man’s continued existence, Tony demonstrates that this is only truly applicable in theory (Camus 78). The mythic Sisyphus can accept radical responsibility for his actions and live in joyful rebellion, but Tony cannot help but succumb to guilt, crippling remorse, and the shackles of external responsibility, beaten down by his failed reconciliation and inability to, until the end of the novel, make sense of the events surrounding him.
The impact of Nietzsche’s project of the ‘revaluation of all values’ in Western thought can possibly be best seen in the artistic sphere, in, for example, Stanley Cavell’s interpretation of the play Endgame by Samuel Beckett. For Cavell, Endgame is about undoing the ‘curses’ of language – associated with positivism – returning us to the ordinary and common sense understandings we have. Thus, the impulse toward too much meaning is undone. Theodore W. Adorno also reads Endgame in Nietzschean fashion, stating that the play is radically devoid of meaning, and that that is its’ point: “authentic” subjectivity and meaningful discourse are no longer possible after the unspeakable events of Auschwitz and the repetition of capitalist relations. For Nietzsche, Western society’s decadence had led it to nihilism, which was not just about destruction, but rather a normal or routine part of the status quo (passive nihilism). I will argue that Nietzsche would see Beckett’s characters in Endgame as prime examples of Last Men, and that therefore he would reject Cavell’s reading of the play. Yet, even though Endgame eschews metaphysics and “grand narratives,” it has its own type of metaphysics: what Adorno calls “micrology." This Nietzschean “anti-foundational” metaphysics is appropriate to the historical situation after World War II, in which metaphysical and lived experience are estranged from each other according to Adorno.
European Online Journal of Natural and Social Sciences, 2013
While this play can be analyzed from different aspects, the psychological aspect has an important contribution to the theme of play. According to different schools characters can be considered the outcome of different forces ; in Marxist view they are products of cultural, economic and ideological forces; according to Darwin and naturalistic views human are outcome of natural selection; according to Freud and Lacan current situation of human are determined by their past, memories, the way they have been brought up, language and whatever characterized their past. In this play there are some references and evidences that support what have said above. Hamm, Clov, Nagg and Nelly are the characters to whom their past are significant. The role of unconscious and its effects on conscious, the repression of their desires, their melancholic response to what has been lost, the master/ slave relationships, the interpretation of dreams, the feeling of abandonment and their relationships to the theme of the play are all aspects that can be examined psychoanalytically in this play.
Wounded Bodies, Wounded Minds, 2014
The aim of this article is to show that the key image in Beckett's play Endgame may be considered a decay of the body and a parallel shrinking of the entire universe. There are no more bike wheels, pap, nature, sugar-plums, navigators, rugs, pain killers or coffins. The absence of the last item points to an image of a landscape of unburied corpses, Hamm remembering Mother Pegg's fear of not being buried. Characters are imprisoned in their bodies, houses and minds and there is a general state of paralysis of the body, Ieading to death or madness. Centres are absent, hence Ham's obsession to be placed by Clov in the centre of the room; bodies are decentered as well. 'Though the imagery in the play may be well related to the context in which it was written, i.e. the world in the aftermath of WWII, we would also like to draw attention to a more Irish background, i.e, the devastation of lreland during the Great Famine in mid-l9th century, the immediate physical consequences and the long-term trauma of the lrish psyche.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.