Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
2015, Visual Anthropology Review
This article argues that a visual focus on suffering bodies can obscure the power relationships that result in inequality and injustice through (1) obscuring the mechanisms and perpetrators of violence, ( ) not disrupting dominant conceptual frameworks, and (3) not leaving room for solutions. I use a corpus of films made about and by a Mexican social movement in San Salvador Atenco to ask a practical question: How might we represent issues of structural violence without focusing on images of suffering and victimization? The solution that these films present is a focus on what I call "scenes of confrontation." [Atenco, documentary film, Mexico, social movements, structural violence] bs_bs_banner
This paper explores the relationship between the female body and violence in three recent Colombian films: Alias María (Rugeles 2015), La sirga (Vega 2012), and Chocó (Hendrix 2012). Despite their differences, they all rely on the embodied experiences of women facing intersectional oppression as the main conduit through which historical violence is actualized. I unpack how the visualization practices used either reinforce nationalistic patriarchal fantasies about the nation as a feminized space in need of saving, or highlight the symbolic violence of such fantasies, carving out spaces of female resistance and agency even in the most violent circumstances.
2012
The use of Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, and other social media in the Arab Spring, #Occupy Wall Street, and Mexico’s #YoSoy132 student movement have all generated excitement about the new uses of digital technology in organized social movements. This dissertation concerns itself with media and social transformation, but recognizes that even as media content can have a deep impact on society and culture, it is ultimately human beings who create and use technology off screen for our own purposes. This dissertation focuses ethnographically on one social movement, the Frente de Pueblos en Defensa de la Tierra (The Peoples’ Front in Defense of Land) of San Salvador Atenco on the outskirts of Mexico City, and their relationships with a range of national and international filmmakers. Through examining the daily practices of producing and distributing social documentary films, I show how people used media as an ethical and political practice to purposefully shape and transform face-to-face human relationships. I argue that filmmaking and distributing was one set of practices through which people attempted to cultivate a collectivist disposition called compañerismo, and through which they could build partial autonomies from the state and corporate capitalism. I argue that the historical shift from ‘resistance’ political practices to ‘autonomy’ practices represents a significant departure for contemporary transnational social movements, and signifies a trend away from a Marxist tradition of organizing and toward greater articulation with anarchist thinking and organizing. The cultivation of compañerismo is part of this shift and is indicative of a partial relocation of objectives away from institutional, legal, and policy changes and toward personal and collective transformations of self. I argue that the intersection between cultural production and self production is a crucial locus for examining how social movements help to bring about elusive social and cultural changes that exist outside the grasp of legal and institutional frameworks. These arguments build from and contribute to three large bodies of anthropological research: a political anthropology interested in social movements, a visual anthropology interested in media production, and a broad theoretical anthropological interest in transformations of self, society, and culture through practice.
“BASTA!” at John Jay College’s Anya and Shiva Art Gallery, revisits the relationship between violence and contemporary art in Latin America. Curators Claudia Calirman and Isabella Villanueva present works by 14 artists from Mexico, Brazil, Argentina, Guatemala, Peru, Colombia, and Venezuela. Latin American artists have always exposed social struggles of their countries, but “BASTA!” focuses on the conflict between representation and reality — inherent in the use of violence as a theme for art. “How to represent violence without aestheticizing it to the level of the banal?” asks Calirman.
Revista de Estudios Hispánicos, 2019
The piece (fixed image or in movement) is a way of communication. This statement has different meanings: on the one hand, the piece as a collective construction with social and historical sense, on the other hand, the symbolic interactions with its visitors, as with its anchorage to an specific time by pointing out violence in Mexico, on top of its argumentative and semantic content. All these elements prompt an interpretative analysis. These contemporary audio-visual speeches lead towards an interpretation, and not a unique or unequivocal interpretation of a fact is not aimed, but, to contribute with an understanding of a certain phenomenon that can be explained through culture, history and the language in a unique and irreplaceable piece. The current iconic production in Mexico incorporates the use of digital technologies (blogs, virtual social networks, etc) and streets as ways to express and represent a speech which stands for some other displays which do not obey commercial parameters, instead they seek action and collective production to face or discuss violence in our country, since this production outstands due to its peculiar aesthetic proposal and its social commitment.
2019
This paper examines recent discourse around gender violence in social media protests in Mexico and a short story collection that anthologizes representations of gender violence in short stories by Mexican women authors as part of a greater genre of anti-feminicide cultural production. I focus my analysis on the hashtag campaigns #MiPrimerAcoso and #SiMeMatan and the microcuento collection ¡Basta! 100 mujeres en contra la violencia de género (Edición mexicana 2014) as ghostly discourses that create a space for breaking the silence of sexual and gendered violence. In these hashtags and micro short stories, I find spectral moments that allow for one to read the stories of gender violence that have been silenced through the discounting of women’s voices and of the recounting of violence against perpetrated against them. The ghostly discourse reveals many representations of gendered violence that resist patriarchal and stereotypical depictions and the haunting presence of those who have ...
The Latin Americanist, 2022
PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review, 2019
Visual Anthropology Review, 2011
This article draws on the authors' experience making a film about pesticide-afflicted ex-banana plantation workers in Nicaragua. Addressed are the practical, ethical, and aesthetic possibilities and challenges of visualizing the bodily dimensions of social inequality through film. How can one represent bodily dimensions of structural violence given the particularity of all visceral knowledge? How can one, in the making of films that travel across cultural and class boundaries, make local epistemologies of suffering felt? Susan Sontag has noted that the West has developed a pornographic appetite for the suffering of others. This appetite connects into a wider economy Gomez-Peña has called the "mainstream bizarre," one in which all that is different-bodies, experiences, persons-in their infinite guises and regardless of their authors' intentions, are consumed in a manner in which they are emptied of political agency. While acknowledging the representational risks and potential pitfalls associated with the graphic showing of affliction, the authors present their strategies and reasoning for doing just this. It is the presence, rather than the absence, of the suffering body that can communicate Nicaraguan pesticide-afflicted protesters' intention of making their pain visible and mediate local body-centered epistemologies of social inequality. [evocation, Nicaragua, pain, pesticide, the senses, suffering, visual representation]
Cristina Rivera Garza’s 2007 novel La muerte me da contributes significantly to current debates over the representation of violence in Mexico and strongly challenges the conventions of generic crime fiction. Her radical rewriting of the novela negra’s iconic corpse encounter initiates a complex reflection on problems of narrative subjectivity, as she turns away from the facile realism of the contemporary novela negra and back toward the self-conscious reflexivity and intertextual play of the Sur group. The novel’s sustained references to visual and performance art (Goya, Abramović, the Chapman brothers) support a nuanced critique of the ethics of representation.
Visual Anthropology, 2016
Images of mass protests that arose from Egypt in early 2011 enraptured global audiences with unexpected scenes of street politics and unprecedented possibilities for political change. While the presence of thousands of cellphone cameras, perhaps hundreds of thousands, provided the technology for a multitude of witnessing, the hyper-visibility of the street in times of protest made image-making practices both threatening and powerful. The recursive rehabilitation of counter-revolutionary images happened on many fronts. Western journalists have long characterized the ''Arab Street'' as a ''barbarous urban mob'' and, despite enchantment with the ''Arab Spring,'' still perpetuated a simplistic analysis of street politics in the region. Meanwhile local television, advertising, and music videos endlessly recycled revolutionary images in superficial modes of patriotic sentimentality; while the urban poor, unable to realize the aims of ''bread, freedom, and social justice,'' have suspiciously remained the unclaimed image of the Egyptian revolution. But by attending to the social life of revolutionary street media, this article reviews the potential for emerging image practice to cultivate new kinds of political subjectivity and collectivity. LIBERATED VISUALITIES It felt like people were fighting the images that had betrayed them for so long-with their own images.
BASTA!: An Exhibition About Art And Violence in Latin America at the Anya and Andrew Shiva Gallery, John Jay College, New York, 2016.
Qualitative Sociology, 2011
2019
Livia K. Stone's Atenco Lives! Filmmaking and Popular Struggle in Mexico is an ethnography of activist film making production and distribution. Stone argues that filmmaking is a tool to advance social change, but not in the ways mainstream technophilic fantasies prime us to expect. Activists use the process of media production, exchange, and distribution as a means to practice the kinds of ethical and nonhierarchical social relations they want to enact more broadly. Forgoing efforts to change or upend state structures, which they experience as hopelessly unjust, these activists instead aim to transform themselves and their communities into ethical collective political subjects. In documenting and analyzing how people use and understand media production as a political tool, Atenco Lives! uncovers how popular activists in Mexico in the first decade of the twentieth century imagined, negotiated, and sought to build nonhierarchical collective power.
2025
Mexico faces a situation of generalized violence, expressed in diverse forms of violence that facilitate and intensify the exploitation of productive and reproductive labor. The government of the “Fourth Transformation” (4T) has made insufficient efforts to deliver justice to sectors of Mexican society made most vulnerable by this situation. In this sense, the 4T does not represent a radical change in the situation of generalized violence that Mexico has experienced since 2006 with the PAN and PRI administrations. Indeed, 4T officials preside over an ongoing production of geographical forms, including “landscapes of disappearance,” that facilitate impunity. Highly visible proponents of the 4T simultaneously seek to delegitimize the justice claims of communities and collectives identified as environmentalist, feminist, Indigenous, or all of the above, which, from a position of exclusion, seek to shape what Luis Tapia would call the “political subsoil”—relations of sociality that exceed the totalizing logic of capitalist and state-territorial projects, reproduced through autonomous forms of solidarity and communication. We argue that aesthetic interventions produced from this position, including “anti-monuments,” express a spatial politics by which activists and community representatives engage in place-making in response to experiences that otherwise are insufficiently recognized by institutionalized power. We focus on the Mexico City megalopolis, in geographies where generalized violence is acutely and variably felt. We understand these aesthetic interventions as signposts that guide—without a pre-established route—a transversal struggle in defense of life.
Porto Arte. Revista de Artes Visuais, 2019
In Mexico, memory has become a battlefield. The Ayotzinapa case (2014) -a still unresolved State-level human rights violation, including the disappearance of 43 students- transformed the public space into a permanent struggle between governmental amnesia and the politics of truth. With the emergence of various massive clandestine graves all across the country, a new form of violence emerged, characterized by the spectral materiality of the absent body. In this article, I elaborate on the relation between disappearance, social memory, and creative activism in recent Mexican art. Using the investigations of Forensic Architecture in Mexico as a case study, the text discusses the role of visual culture in the articulation of what I call the performativity of human rights.
This article explores how Mariana Rondón's award-winning Venezuelan film Pelo malo (2013) reveals the inner workings of private relationships and language, representing what Bourdieu termed " symbolic violence ". Pelo malo challenges the exponential celebratory boom in Venezuelan state-supported filmmaking as the Chávez administration turned to cinema to narrate the nation. Despite the excitement and increase in state-sponsored filmmaking and the Chávez era's nation-building discourse, Pelo malo exposes the limits of Chávez' imagined community in both the film's plot and its post-production trajectory.
2018
Neoliberalism is more than an economic system, it’s a cultural frame for the production of heterogeneous signs, it is a semiotic operator whose semiotics are both signifying and a-signifying (Deleuze & Guattari; Lazzarato); for that reason it is necessary to explore and analyze the ways in which art objects work with several languages and concepts to produce sensitive records of exclusions and negotiations within the economic territories created by globalization. Taking as starting point the proposal by Alexander R. Galloway to think the interface as a mediation space and an autonomous zone of activity, I propose the critical reading of texts that have been written as an aesthetic response to the horrorism of financial economy, specially those that work with the materiality of the text that can be seen as a work with the «submedial space» of the Archive (Groys): Hugo Garcia Manriquez's Anti-Humboldt (Aldus/Litmus Press, 2015); Eugenio Tisselli’s The 27th / 27th (motorhueso.net, 2014), Mónica Nepote’s Hechos diversos (Acapulco, 2010; some of the poems of the book have been translated by John Pluecker and published in some reviews) and Sara Uribe's Antígona González (Les Figues Press, 2016). The paper focus in the work with critical forms that articulate the violence of capital and its relationship with the media ecology of contemporary literature through the use of two main concepts: body and the writing. The main aim is to theorize their multiplicity as modes of reterritorialization of violence in the neoliberal age.
Transforming Anthropology, 2020
This article addresses the ways in which Afro-Colombians in the region of María la Baja, Colombia, re-signify their contentious bodies amidst parallel peace and war efforts. After over sixty years of war, the government and armed paramilitary forces continue to frame Afro-Colombian campesinos (rural farmers) as both innocent victims and guerrilla combatants. Given the legacies of racialized marginalization, how do Afro-Colombian communities stake claims to lost land and violent pasts when their very bodies are presumed to challenge their innocence? I illustrate how individuals use their contentious bodies to resist militant and bureaucratic attempts to label them as perpetrators of violence. Afro-Colombian farmers enact embodied evidence, such as calloused farming hands, to assert their dignity and victimization. Through these corporeal and visual self-assertions, I examine the ways in which intersectional signifiers—including territory, ethnicity, gender, and class—are simultaneously read and performed within the context of war and peacetime violence.
Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies, 2015
This article examines the politics of gender in armed guerrilla organizations during Mexico's Dirty War (1960 and the role of visual culture in documenting histories of state violence and revolutionary struggle. By centering specifically on Mexican film-maker Luisa Riley's documentary Flor en Otomí (2012), this article explores the possibilities and limitations of visual culture in representing gendered histories of trauma in recent Mexican history. As one of the few cultural texts that documents women's participation in the history of Mexico's armed socialist organizations, the film alludes to the difficulty of audiovisually portraying violence and the tensions that emerge when representing the gendered ghosts of Mexico's Dirty War. Ultimately, this article argues that the eradication of thousands of (gendered) subjectivities from Mexico's national consciousness has created a gendered haunting that holds contemporary neoliberal Mexico accountable to its recent violent past.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.