Cleaner production alternatives: Biomass utilisation options
Peter Mizsey2010, Journal of Cleaner Production
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
The increasing price of energy, the security of supply, the reduction of green house gases, and the scarcity of oil and gas urge the use of more and more renewable energy. An important renewable energy source is the biomass which can be applied for heat, electricity, and transportation fuel production. The heat and electricity production are the so called ''direct utilisation'' alternatives and the transportation fuel production alternatives are the ''indirect utilisation'' alternatives of biomass energy. If efficient land use is considered, the alternatives can be compared on the basis of the utilisable energy produced from the biomass per hectare. It is shown that the bioethanol production from corn has about 89-99% less energy production capability than that of the direct utilisation alternatives. The cellulosic type bioethanol production technologies, since these partially directly utilise the biomass energy, have better energy utilisation potential, that is about 40-50% of direct alternatives.
Related papers
Energy from biomass: alternative for the reduction of atmospheric emissions
Lámpsakos
Biomass produces the same amount of emissions of carbon dioxide absorbed during its growth that means that emits the same amount of CO2 processing during part of its life cycle, making it neutral emissions of carbon compounds. The mass use of this energy source in developing countries with high agricultural potential is not considered feasible. This article from a research project describes the processes for biomass utilization and environmental benefits of using this energy resource that has been booming in different countries. It is concluded that although it is feasible the inclusion of biomass for energysupply, exists a lack of guidelines for sustainable use.
The Use of Biomass as an Alternative Energy
2017
The focus of the research is to investigate the advantages of biomass as an alternative energy source to prevent or reduce the additional emissions of greenhouse gases; that is released from the conventional fuels combustion. A study also put a spot of light on the potential of different sources which can produce good amount of biomass as fuel feed stock. It is clear that biomass can be used as an alternative source of energy if the mentioned recommendations are done.
Plant Production for Biomass into Energy: Economics and Energy Efficiency View
Applied Studies in Agribusiness and Commerce, 2016
The aim of the paper was to determine the influence of the fertilization level on the energy and economics efficiency of the production technologies of selected crops processed into bioethanol or biogas. There were investigated the following crops: rye, triticale, wheat, sugar beets, maize, sorghum, reed canarygrass and Virginia fanpetals. In the energetic efficiency the Energy Return on Energy Investment index (EroEI) was used. Apart from the ERoEI ratio, the Net Energy Value (NEV) ratio was also used. In the economics efficiency attitude, the Gross Margin (GM) was determined.The investigations proved that in general, the production technologies of crops where the lowest levels of nitrogen fertilization were applied proved to have the highest energetic efficiency. The highest economic efficiency was characterized by the production of corn for biogas. In the case of the production of bioethanol (all plants), ratios were on the verge of profitability or the lack of it showed.The anal...
Biomass energy in industrialised countries—a view of the future
Forest Ecology and Management, 1997
Biomass fuels currently (1994) supply around 14% of the world's energy, but most of this is in the form of traditional fuelwood, residues and dung, which is often inefficient and can be environmentally detrimental. Biomass can supply heat and electricity, liquid and gaseous fuels. A number of developed countries derive a significant amount of their primary energy from biomass: USA 4%, Finland 18%, Sweden 16% and Austria 13%. Presently biomass energy supplies at least 2 EJ year−1 in Western Europe which is about 4% of primary energy (54 EJ). Estimates show a likely potential in Europe in 2050 of 9.0–13.5 EJ depending on land areas (10% of useable land, 33 Mha), yields (10–15 oven-dry tonnes (ODt) ha−1), and recoverable residues (25% of harvestable). This biomass contribution represents 17–30% of projected total energy requirements up to 2050. The relative contribution of biofuels in the future will depend on markets and incentives, on continuous research and development progress, and on environmental requirements. Land constraints are not considered significant because of the predicted surpluses in land and food, and the near balance in wood and wood products in Europe.There is considerable potential for the modernisation of biomass fuels to produce convenient energy carriers such as electricity, gases and transportation fuels, whilst continuing to provide for traditional uses of biomass; this modernisation of biomass and the industrial investment is already happening in many countries. When produced in an efficient and sustainable manner, biomass energy has numerous environmental and social benefits compared with fossil fuels. These include improved land management, job creation, use of surplus agricultural land in industrialised countries, provision of modern energy carriers to rural communities of developing countries, a reduction of CO2 levels, waste control, and nutrient recycling. Greater environmental and net energy benefits can be derived from perennial and woody energy cropping than from annual arable crops which are short-term alternative feedstocks for fuels. Agroforestry systems can play an important role in providing multiple benefits to growers and the community, besides energy. In order to ameliorate CO2 emissions, using biomass as a substitute for fossil fuels (complete replacement, co-firing, etc.) is more beneficial from social and economic perspectives than sequestering the carbon in forests.Case studies are presented for several developed countries and the constraints involved in modernising biomass energy along with the potential for turning them into entrepreneurial opportunities are discussed. It is concluded that the long term impacts of biomass programmes and projects depend mainly on ensuring income generation, environmental sustainability, flexibility and replicability, while taking account of local conditions and providing multiple benefits, which is an important attribute of agroforestry-type systems. Biomass for energy must be environmentally acceptable in order to ensure its widespread adoptions as a modern energy source. Implementation of biomass projects requires governmental policy initiatives that will internalise the external economic, social and environmental costs of conventional fuel sources so that biomass fuels can become competitive on a ‘level playing field’.
Using full energetic potential of plant biomass in production of bioethanol
The process of bioethanol production from non-edible of plant biomass (bagasse, corn stover and switchgrass) has been studied. This process included pretreatment of the initial biomass (IB) with dilute acid, enzymatic saccharification, conversion of fermentable sugar into ethanol and distillation of the hydrated alcohol. It was shown that about 20% of IB only are spent for production of bioethanol, while about of 55% of IB remained as solid residues. The calorimetric measurements and calculations revealed that the residues have energetic potential of 20 MJ/kg. Thus, burning of all amounts of the accumulated residues yields about 3.2 MWh of energy for $320. As it follows from economic calculations, the income from utilization of solid residues for energy generation covers the main part of total expenses, which reduces the final production price of bioethanol to $1.2 per gal. As a result, the production of fuel ethanol from non-food plant biomass can be competitive. Furthermore, utilization of the solid waste decreases expenses of their transportation and landfilling.
Utilization of Biomass for Renewable Bio Energy Development
This communication discusses a comprehensive review of biomass energy sources, environment and sustainable development. This includes all the biomass energy technologies, energy efficiency systems, energy conservation scenarios, energy savings and other mitigation measures necessary to reduce emissions globally. The current literature is reviewed regarding the ecological, social, cultural and economic impacts of biomass technology. This study gives an overview of present and future use of biomass as an industrial feedstock for production of fuels, chemicals and other materials. However, to be truly competitive in an open market situation, higher value products are required. Results suggest that biomass technology must be encouraged, promoted, invested, implemented, and demonstrated, but especially in remote rural areas.
Degree of Biomass Conversion in the Integrated Production of Bioethanol and Biogas
Energies
The integrated production of bioethanol and biogas makes it possible to optimise the production of carriers from renewable raw materials. The installation analysed in this experimental paper was a hybrid system, in which waste from the production of bioethanol was used in a biogas plant with a capacity of 1 MWe. The main objective of this study was to determine the energy potential of biomass used for the production of bioethanol and biogas. Based on the results obtained, the conversion rate of the biomass—maize, in this case—into bioethanol was determined as the efficiency of the process of bioethanol production. A biomass conversion study was conducted for 12 months, during which both maize grains and stillage were sampled once per quarter (QU-I, QU-II, QU-III, QU-IV; QU—quarter) for testing. Between 342 L (QU-II) and 370 L (QU-I) of ethanol was obtained from the organic matter subjected to alcoholic fermentation. The mass that did not undergo conversion to bioethanol ranged from ...
Energy production from biomass (part 1): overview of biomass
Bioresource Technology, 2002
The use of renewable energy sources is becoming increasingly necessary, if we are to achieve the changes required to address the impacts of global warming. Biomass is the most common form of renewable energy, widely used in the third world but until recently, less so in the Western world. Latterly much attention has been focused on identifying suitable biomass species, which can provide high-energy outputs, to replace conventional fossil fuel energy sources. The type of biomass required is largely determined by the energy conversion process and the form in which the energy is required. In the first of three papers, the background to biomass production (in a European climate) and plant properties is examined. In the second paper, energy conversion technologies are reviewed, with emphasis on the production of a gaseous fuel to supplement the gas derived from the landfilling of organic wastes (landfill gas) and used in gas engines to generate electricity. The potential of a restored landfill site to act as a biomass source, providing fuel to supplement landfill gas-fuelled power stations, is examined, together with a comparison of the economics of power production from purpose-grown biomass versus waste-biomass. The third paper considers particular gasification technologies and their potential for biomass gasification. Ó
Sustainable agriculture and the production of biomass for energy use
Climatic Change, 2009
Modern bioenergy is seen as a promising option to curb greenhouse gas emissions. There is, however, a potential competition for land and water between bioenergy and food crops. Another question is whether biomass for energy use can be produced in a sustainable manner given the current conventional agricultural production practices. Other than the land and water competition, this question is often neglected in scenarios to meet a significant part of global energy demand with bioenergy. In the following, I address this question.
Analysis of Plant-Production-Obtained Biomass in Function of Sustainable Energy
Sustainability
This research analyzed the degree of utilization of the agricultural biomass for energy purposes (combustion), in order to indicate the reasons that limit its use. The biomass potential was studied by means of the methodology of the biomass potential, whereas the factors suggesting a low degree of biomass utilization were identified by means of factor analysis. The research results reveal that there is an enormous potential of the unused agricultural biomass. This dissertation research significantly contributes to the establishment of a genuine mathematical model based on multiple linear regression. The solution obtained by this analysis, in both a mathematical and a scientific manner, conveys the primary reasons for an insufficient utilization of the biomass for energy purposes. Moreover, the paper suggests the measures to be applied for a more substantial use of this renewable source of energy and presents the expected benefits to be gained.
Optimisation of the use of biomass for energy production (Optimierung der energetischen Biomassenutzung)--a funding programme introduces itself
Energy, Sustainability and Society, 2011
In 2009 the German funding programme for "Promoting Projects to Optimise the Use of Biomass for Energy Production" ("Biomass for Energy") has started and fostered a wide range of projects to combine sustainable energy supply and climatic protection. Certain projects are described to give an idea of the wide range of projects and the different aspects of sustainability which are addressed. Additionally a first product for the planned quality assurance of the results via a dedicated method handbook is given.
The analysis of the potential for biomass exploitation in the context of bio-economy. Case study: wheat and maize crops
Romanian Biotechnological Letters, 2020
The future evolution of the energy sector, the challenges faced by industry, the growth premise, and the role that agriculture plays as a source of energy are key elements of the bio-economy. Biomass production in the vegetal agricultural sector is in line with the concept of sustainable development, reduces carbon dioxide emissions through photosynthetic processes and ensures the development of raw materials and renewable energy resources. This article proposed both an economic analysis of biomass potential, represented by the secondary production obtained in wheat and maize crops, for the period 2008-2017, as well as an estimation of the market value of the secondary production correlated with the potential for capitalizing those two crops. The exploitation of the potential of the secondary production is reflected in the production of bioenergy (thermal, electric) and biofuels, respectively, both for use as animal feed and fertilization of agricultural land, as well as non-polluting biofuels.
Biomass requirements for power production: how to optimise the quality by agricultural management
Biomass and Bioenergy, 1997
Biomass Potential and Availability for Energetic Use – Barriers and Drivers
2008
Biomass availability and potential has a lot of aspect including technical (i.e. land management, energy and moisture content of the biomass, grid connection, logistic issues…), environmental (i.e. erosion, soil compaction, nutrient input, pesticide, water abstraction, fire risk, biodiversity…) and economic (i.e. cost-supply, competition, prices, support schemes…) considerations. There are a lot of research about the suitable biomass crop mixes and their assesssment, development and sustainability and a lot of existing models try to predict the future compatible biomass potential. Our research focuses on the collection of the national, regional cases and also on a comparative analysis of the main forms of biomass. As a result a priorization of bioenergy crops and the main barriers and drivers in different regions for the sustainable bioenergy will be summarized.
Production of Biofuels from Biomass as an Approach Towards Sustainable Development: A Short Review
2022
Alternative fuels reduce the carbon footprint of internal combustion engines. Biofuels are the most important alternative fuels. Manufacturing processes for biofuels have made it possible to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from well to wheel. There are a number of popular alternative fuels for use in internal combustion (IC) engines, including biodiesel, bioethanol, and bio methanol. Biodiesel and petroleum diesel fuel blends in compression ignition (CI) engines have received a lot of attention. Biofuel is any liquid fuel derived from "biomass," such as plants and animal waste. Biofuels replace gasoline and diesel. Biofuels are promising because the carbon dioxide (CO2) they emit is recycled through the environment. Biofuel plants collect CO2 from the air and release it when burned. In principle, biofuels can be a "carbon neutral" or "carbon negative" means to power automobiles, trucks, and planes. Biofuels can reduce CO2 emissions without requiring many infrastructural changes. They can be used in existing cars and mass-produced from biomass like chemicals and pharmaceuticals. Future biofuels may be moved using current pipelines. Making carbon-neutral biofuels is difficult. Fermentation, processing energy, transportation, and even plant nutrients can produce CO2 and other greenhouse gases before biofuels are consumed. Biomass agriculture can have climate consequences if it replaces CO2-storing woods. How biofuels are generated and used affects their potential as a climate solution.
Biomass for Energy
1989
This paper provides a broad overview of the use of plant material as a source of usable energy. The problem ofgathering and interpreting data on the use of biomass is discussed. From the limited data available it is inferred that bioenergy contributes about 15% of the global energy budget. The paper deals with a variety ofother major topics: the role ofbiomass in the energy system, differences in that role in industrialized and developing countries, conversion technologies, environmental considerations and the multiple uses of biomass (food for people, feed for animals and fibre for construction material and other uses as well as energy sources). The ability of the biosphere to provide adequate amounts ofprimary energy is limited, especially ifforecasts of population growth, and associated increases in the demand for food, feed and fibre, turn out to be accurate. By improvingthe efficiency ofbioenergy use, which is currently very low, it should be possible to deliver more tertiary energy for the same primary energy input.
Utilisation of biomass for the supply of energy carriers
Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology, 1999
Because biomass is a widely available, renewable resource, its utilisation for the production of energy has great potential for reducing CO 2 emissions and thereby preventing global warming. In this mini-review the`state of the art' of several fermentation processes is discussed, starting with the most advanced process of ethanol production. This is followed by methane production, an established process for waste water puri®cation which is gaining more attention because of the inherent energy production. Subsequently ABE fermentation is discussed and ®nally the biological production of hydrogen. The last section proposes a new way to assess and compare the dierent processes by relating their merit to`work content' values and`lost work' instead of the combustion values of their products. It is argued that, especially when dealing with energy from biomass, the application of this methodology will provide a uniform valuation for dierent processes and products. The described fermentation processes enable the supply of pure energy carriers, either gaseous or liquid, from biomass, yet the introduction of these processes is hampered by two major problems. The ®rst is related to technological shortcomings in the mobilisation of fermentable components from the biomass. The second, having a much greater impact, is linked with socio-economics: until full externality costs are attributed to fossil fuels, accounting for their role in pollution and global warming, the competitiveness of the processes described here will hardly stand a chance.
Potential for Biomass and Biofuel through Sustainable Intensification of Agriculture and Reduction of Food Losses and Waste
Substantial potential exists to expand supplies of biomass for energy applications through more systematic collection of agricultural residues, more intensive cultivation of croplands, and reduced waste and losses in the food chain. This study aims to show how the potential can be calculated from public information sources, to put the potential in the context of global needs for liquid transport fuels, and to suggest some practical policy options for bringing part of the potential to market. It finds that if the theoretical potential is fully realized, enough liquid biofuel could be produced to displace the equivalent of all current global liquid fuel use for transport.
Analysis of Sustainable Biomass: A Three-Dimensional Approach
2011
This paper aims to identify the possibilities of biomass to become more sustainable using a three-dimensional approach that seeks to integrate the economic, social and environmental concerns arisen from the production and use of biomass. This objective encompasses a critical analysis of the challenges faced by biomass. The first goal resides in clarifying the variety of biomass feedstock by exploring its definitions by different normative acts and by introducing a new classification in different categories depending on their sustainability. This explanation also contains considerations regarding origin, composition, characteristics and conversion routes for biomass. The second goal has in view to determine the Advantages and Barriers faced by biomass, accompanied by Corrective actions (ABC analysis). The main findings reveal the great variety of biomass resources that are facing multiple challenges and an inconsistency in defining it at international level. Consequently, a biomass differentiation is introduced by placing sustainability safeguards to different biomass resources. This recommends the use of the term biomass only for residues and wastes derived from agriculture and forestry, while the other resources should bear a name correlated with their specificity (bio-cultures, bio-wastes and bio-tech).
Recent Findings and the Energetic Potential of Plant Biomass as a Renewable Source of Biofuels – A Review
2015
Nowadays the main sources of energy are petroleum, coal, and natural gas. However, these fossil sources are not reproduced in nature; on a human timescale their reserves are exhausted permanently and run down. Considerable attention in recent years has been given to plant biomass, which in contrast to the fossil sources is continuously renewed in nature. In this critical review the use of non-edible plant biomass for production of various kinds of biofuels is considered. To generate energy, plant biomass either can be burned directly or it can be used after its conversion into carbonized solid fuel (e.g. biochar), liquid fuels (bioethanol, biodiesel, bio-oil), or gases (biogas). Among various biofuels, production of bioethanol has potential to be the most attractive if recent technological advances become implemented, such that the co-production of ethanol and valuable byproducts can be combined together with recycling of solid and liquid wastes. A comparative analysis of energetic ...
Related topics
Cited by
Design and engineering of sustainable process systems and supply chains by the P-graph framework
Environmental progress & sustainable energy, 2018
The design of sustainable manufacturing processes and supply chains is rapidly becoming a critical issue. The reason is the necessity of providing for the needs of a growing human population which is increasingly prosperous across the globe. To this purpose, this review article explores the most important elements of sustainability science and couples them with the P-graph framework, thereby rendering it possible to design feasible process and supply structures with great ease. Structure is an often-overlooked aspect of process and supply chain design, in part because even relative simple processes or supply chains can have an enormous number of feasible structures. We further illustrate the application of these ideas with examples of energy generation processes and supply chains. V
Evaluation of microalgae-based biorefinery alternatives
Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy, 2016
Microalgae-based biorefineries for the production of renewable biofuels like biodiesel, upgraded bio-oil, biochar, biogas and other high-value chemicals have received great attention in recent decades as potential major sources of energy for the future. Microalgae are a suitable species to produce biodiesel and other high energy density by-products; however, it is questionable whether a net energy gain can be realized or not considering the whole processing chain. In the present study, the energy balances of different algae-based biofuel and bioenergy production technologies are investigated in detail and compared to each other corresponding to a cradle-to-grave overall energetic analysis. The study includes cultivation, harvesting, cell pretreatments (cell disruption, drying, grinding), lipid extraction, transesterification, gasification and hydrothermal liquefaction with bio-oil stabilization and hydroprocessing. The energy consumption and energy gain are estimated for each operational step to determine the net energy ratio (NER, energy output over energy input) for the overall technologies studied. Our detailed investigation enables to detect the most energy consuming unit operation, that is, the bottleneck point(s) of the microalgae-based technologies which should be still improved in the future for the sake of more efficient algaebased biorefineries. The investigation makes also possible to evaluate and compare the different large scale alternatives for biomass transformation. Positive energy balances with a NER value of 1.109 and 1.137 are found in two already existing processes: open raceway ponds and closed photobioreactors, respectively. Our work gives also a detailed algorithm that can be followed at the evaluation of other microalgae-based biorefineries.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.