Business cycles in a balance-of-payments constrained growth framework
Luis Alberto Rivas2016, Economic Modelling
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
The main goal of this work is to analyze the potential implications of the balance-of-payments constraint theory for business cycles. Although this theory is oriented towards long-run growth, it implicitly predicts the existence of cycles in any open economy. As we try to show, according to this theory, business cycles are generated by two factors: capital flows and trade shocks. Yet the standard model can overestimate cycles due to its specification of trade equations. In the paper we first develop the implications of the balance-of-payments constraint theory with regard to business cycles, then build an augmented model that can correct the potential over-estimation of cycles: Finally we use that model to analyze the sources of business cycles in Portugal and Spain and to show that the standard model does indeed overestimate cycles, at least in these two cases.
Related papers
Application of the balance-of-payments-constrained growth model to Portugal, 1965-2008
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 2011
The present study aims to verify whether the balance-of-paymentsconstrained growth approach is suitable for explaining the Portuguese growth performance during the past decades. To smooth cyclical variations, 15-year overlapping periods are considered in the computation of "Thirlwall's law," assuming that income elasticity of imports is either constant or variable over time. It is shown that actual growth can accurately be predicted by the ratio of export growth to the income elasticity of the demand for imports. Evidence also reveals that Portugal grew slightly faster than the rate consistent with the balance-of-payments equilibrium accumulating external deficits over time. Considering the pre-and postaccession periods to the European Union, it is found that Portugal grew at a slower rate in the latter period, explained by a higher income elasticity of imports and lower export growth.
The Spanish Business Cycle and its Relationship to Europe
1998
This paper studies the relationship between the Spanish real aggregate uctuations and those of its European neighbors in the last decades. It studies the ability o f alternative I n ternational Real Business Cycle models based on Backus, Kehoe and Kydland 1994 with di erent degrees of international interdependencies, to capture the observed comovement b e t ween the Spanish and European business cycles and compares the t of those models using a probabilistic measure based on and Canova 1994. We nd that i common shocks are important and that ii mechanisms of international transmission of shocks other than trade in consumption goods and services and spillovers in total factor productivity shocks are required in order to explain the joint uctuations between Spain and its European neighbors. I w ant to thank Fabio Canova, Finn Kydland, Morten Ravn, V ctor R os-Rull, Angel Ubide and Javier Vall es for very useful suggestions. All remaining errors are mine.
Macroeconomic Regimes Business Cycle Theories Reconsidered
The disequilibrium framework is extended to account for investment-savings imbalances that are likely to affect capital accumulation. A simple graphical analysis is put forward to analyse the additional regimes arising out of this imbalance and different adjustment mechanisms are discussed. These different regimes are compared with existing business cycle theories, showing that this framework does allow to analyse approaches as different as Keynesian, Classical and Austrian business cycle theories. Finally, these regimes are used to put forward an alternative explanation for the dynamics of European unemployment and the possible persistent effects of misperceptions by policy makers.
Business cycles and trends in Germany and Portugal: macroeconomic policy implications in the Euro Area
European Planning Studies, 2020
We describe the business cycle neoclassical view adopted by European Institutions in the Euro Area, and derive the stylized facts of business cycles and trends for Germany and Portugal in the period 1991-2018. The data is extracted from the European Commission's AMECO database. To separate cycle and trend, we use the decomposition available in the AMECO database for the output, and the the Hodrick-Prescott filter for the other variables. The results show that the amplitude of the business cycle and persistence of shocks are greater in Portugal than in Germany. They also show that the stylized facts of the business cycles of the two economies are quite different. Moreover, common shocks have asymmetric consequences. In the long run, there has been a convergence of inflation, general government structural balances, and real unit labour costs, but general government consolidated gross debt, fixed investment, and per capita potential GDP have been increasingly diverging, despite the behaviour of real wages and net exports in the two countries. Additionally, temporary shocks have permanent effects on the Portuguese economy. The results raise questions about the place-neutral macroeconomic policy enforced by the European institutions in the Euro Area, particularly in what concerns cohesion Member States.
International business cycles: What are the facts
Journal of Monetary Economics, 2004
Modern business cycle theory involves developing models that explain stylized facts. For this strategy to be successful, these facts should be well established. In this paper, we focus on the stylized facts of international business cycles. We use the generalized method of moments and quarterly data from twenty industrialized countries to estimate and test hypotheses concerning pairwise cross-country correlations of macroeconomic aggregates. A remarkable common feature emerges: these correlations are mostly positive, not very high and of a similar order of magnitude. The most important discrepancy with the theory is the low cross-country correlation of consumption. r 1 See also Baxter (1995) for a broad survey of international business cycle models. Switzerland, the United Kingdom, the United States, and an aggregate of European countries. 3 Although BKK do not report standard errors for the predictions of their stochastic simulations, these predictions are insensitive to the numerical values used to calibrate the baseline model and to sampling uncertainty in drawing the random shocks. 4 In addition DGE models do not generate fluctuations in the terms of trade as large as those observed in the data. Models which restrict the elasticity of substitution between domestic and foreign goods can generate volatile terms of trade, but at the cost of a counterfactually low volatility of the trade balance. 5 Backus and Kehoe (1992) estimate the cross-correlations of output using GMM techniques applied to annual data on nine different countries. They report standard errors for individual country pairs but do not derive the implied standard errors for their entire panel of data.
Business cycle theories and their relevance to the current global crisis
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2012
Ever since the onset of the recent crisis, monetary business cycle theories have started to regain their relevance and timeliness in explaining business fluctuations. According to these theories, it is monetary mismanagement that lies at the bottom of macroeconomic dysfunctions in the intertemporal allocation of resources. This paper presents the main theoretical implications of monetary business cycle models, regarding the causes of the cycle and the appropriate policies required to overcome recessions. In addition, we investigate whether, at the policy level, macroeconomists are indeed addressing the causes of the business cycle, in order to provide feasible solutions to end recessions.
Comparing general and partial equilibrium approaches to the study of real business cycles
The international …nancial crises and deepening worldwide recession remind us that the economic fates of nations are tightly linked. How do di¤erent models perform in explaining correlated business cycles? This paper compares the performance of two types of international real business cycle models, namely two-country dynamic stochastic general equilibrium (DSGE) and small open economy (SOE) models in explaining the shock transmission mechanisms across countries, using 68 countries' output and consumption data from the Penn World Table (PWT). In particular, we put our emphasis on the two types of models that have both permanent and transitory components of productivity shocks. In the two-country DSGE model, comovement of business cycles among di¤erent countries can be captured by correlated permanent and transitory components of productivities across countries. On the other hand, in the SOE model, comovement of economies can only be modeled through the channel of world interest rate shock. Our evidence shows that the interest rate shock has very limited impact on output growth. Therefore, the two-country DSGE model outperforms the SOE in capturing the e¤ects of the permanent shocks originated from foreign countries, especially for the developed countries, which are highly integrated with each other.
Business cycles in a small open economy with a banking sector
2001
This paper studies the interest-rate-driven business cycles of a small open economy (SOE). For than end a costly operated banking system is added to the standard real-business-cycles model. Banks are the only domestic agents considered worthy of credit in international capital markets. They borrow from the rest of the world and lend domestically in a competitive credit market. Existent quantitative models of business cycles in SOE's indicate that interest-rate shocks are unable to cast the kind of output variability produced by productivity or terms-of-trade shocks. Contrary to this finding, it seems that the macroeconomic performances of several SOE's are tightly related to international interest rates and capital flows. Neumeyer and Perri (1999) points out that the introduction of working capital needs may close the gap between the standard model's predictions and the observed consequences of interest-rate shocks. This paper shows that a more careful analysis of the microfoundations of working capital may give rise to an intermediate position where working capital matters in explaining output fluctuations, but not as much as Neumayer and Perri suggest. For that end, the model is calibrated to the Argentinean economy.
16. Real business cycle models, endogenous growth models and cyclical growth: a critical survey
2002
Since the early contributions to the topic, business cycles have been considered as essentially connected with the development of capitalist economies. In the early 1980s the issue of the relationship between growth and cycles was addressed within a market clearing environment by the real business cycle (RBC) literature, and, more recently, in endogenous growth (EG) models. 1
Financial Frictions in Business Cycles, Trade and Growth
2001
This dissertation is about the role of financial frictions in the business cycles, trade and growth. First, I analyze what is the role of asymmetric information problems between borrowers and lenders in the business cycles, and second, I study the role of imperfect enforcement in financial contracts on a typical country's trade and growth patterns. In Chapter 1, I show how asymmetric information problems between banks and firms can be responsible for producing endogenous long lasting recession both at the micro and macroeconomic levels after an external shock on the interest rate faced by a small open economy. The only source of shocks is through the international interest rate or through the country risk, and the main transmission mechanism appears because banks do not observe the firms' expected productivity. In this environment, banks can infer the average quality of the firms taking each type of credit contract by observing the firms' age and net worth, thus determining credit conditions.
Related papers
International business cycles in theory and in practice
Journal of International Money and Finance, 1997
This paper investigates whether multi-country international business models can account for international comovements. In the OECD there are substantial positive comovements between many output components, between levels of employment, and between total factor productivities. The standard international business cycle model is not consistent with these comovements. Except for consumption levels, the model implies either negative or very low comovements. This is a robust feature of the theoretical models independently of specific parameter values. One interesting finding is that a more general specification of the technology shock processes lead to substantial comovements but at the cost of another deficiency. (JEL E32, E62).
Balance-of-payments constrained growth: a post Keynesian model with capital inflows
Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 2013
Libânio • CEDEPLAR/UFGM RESUMO Neste trabalho propomos uma breve análise teórica sobre a relação entre mobilidade internacional de capitais e crescimento econômico, aqui observada sob a perspectiva do crescimento liderado pela demanda. O trabalho está organizado em quatro seções além da introdução. Inicialmente, evocamos brevemente as proposições centrais que constituem a concepção de crescimento liderado pela demanda. Na seção seguinte, o modelo de crescimento com restrição no balanço de pagamentos proposto por Thirlwall (1979) é revisto e desenvolvimentos posteriores, que buscam incorporar o papel dos fluxos de capital nesse arcabouço analítico, são analisados. Com base nesses elementos desenvolvemos, em seguida, um modelo teórico com vistas a estudar a relação entre crescimento com restrição externa e controle de capitais, formalmente introduzido como uma variável de política macroeconômica. Na parte final do ensaio, são traçadas considerações finais sobre o modelo. Palavras-chave: crescimento econômico, restrição externa, controle de capitais ABSTRACT This paper proposes a brief theoretical analysis of the relationship between international capital mobility and economic growth, seen in the perspective of demand-led growth. The work comprises four sections, besides the introduction. First of all, we briefly present the central propositions that constitute the so-called demand-led growth perspective. We then review the balance-of-payments constrained growth model, as originally proposed by Thirlwall (1979), as well as subsequent efforts to incorporate capital flows into this analytical framework. Building on this theoretical structure, a model is proposed in order to study the connections between balance-of-payments constrained growth and capital controls, which is formally introduced as a macroeconomic policy variable. In the last section, we present the final remarks on this model.
International Trade and the Business Cycle
1997
This paper develops a new empirical framework for analysing the dynamics of the trade balance in response to different types of macroeconomic shocks. The model provides a synthetic perspective on the conditional correlations between the business cycle and the trade balance that are generated by different shocks and attempts to reconcile these results with unconditional correlations found in the data. The results suggest that, in the post-Bretton Woods period, nominal shocks have been an important determinant of the forecast error variance for¯uctuations in the trade balance in G-7 countries.
A framework for measuring international business cycles
International Journal of Forecasting, 2001
The classical measurement of business cycles, growth cycles, and growth rate cycles lies at the foundation for the understanding of macroeconomic dynamics in open market economies. This essay presents a framework for analyzing and forecasting cyclical behavior in economic activity, employment, and inflation. The framework is extended to foreign trade and important domestic sectors of an economy such as manufacturing, services, and construction. This multidimensional framework, which allows for a more in-depth analysis, serves as a model to be developed on a comparable basis across countries. Business cycle and growth rate cycle reference chronologies, which have been determined for the major economies, are presented in this context.
How well the balance-of-payments constraint approach explains the Portuguese growth performance. Empirical evidence for the 1965-2008 period
2009
The present study aims to verify whether the balance-of-payments constrained growth approach is suitable for explaining the Portuguese growth performance during the last decades. For that, we adopt “Thirlwall’s Law” that predicts actual growth by the ratio of the exports growth relative to the income-elasticity of the demand for imports. The income-elasticity of imports, essential for the entire analysis, is obtained from the estimation of the imports function by 2SLS, assuming that domestic growth is endogenous. To smooth cyclical variations, 15-year overlapping periods are considered in the computation of “Thirlwall’s Law”, assuming that income-elasticity with respect to imports is either constant or variable over time. It is found that the Law is a good instrument for predicting actual growth in Portugal and this result is reinforced by performing the McCombie test. Our results reveal that Portugal grew slightly higher relatively to the OECD countries in the entire period and thi...
International business cycles: how much can standard theory account for?
1993
In this paper I first provide some empirical facts of international business cycles. I then investigate whether standard international real business cycle models can account for these moments of the data. I find that the standard theories seem unable to account for key-features of the data. For some variables (like consumption levels) theory predicts too high international comovements while it has the opposite implication for other variables (e.g. investment and output). Simple extensions do not improve the performance by much and stochastic shocks to government spending seem to have only minor effects in open-economy real business cycle models.
Potential Growth and Business Cycle in the Spanish Economy: Implications for Fiscal Policy!
2007
An accurately estimation of the cyclical position of an economy is a necessary condition for the success of fiscal stabilisation policies. In this paper we show that the estimation of the output gap by means of decomposing a production function produces similar results to univariate and multivariate methods, increasing their robustness and allowing us to conclude that most of the information on the economic cycle is included in the cyclical component of the unemployment rate. The results also indicate that there is reduced uncertainty about the periods when the Spanish economy has clearly been in a deep recession or in a sharp expansion. These periods have been limited and of relatively short duration. Fiscal policy should pay particular attention to these episodes, when discretionary stabilisation policies make most sense.
Economic growth and the balance-of-payments constraint: The case of the Spanish regions
Our paper examines the long run relationship between economic growth and the current account balance equilibrium by relying on the BoP constrained growth model. We find that Vietnam grew less than the rate predicted when the period 1985 to 2010 as a whole is considered, but with different behavior for the 1998-2010 sub-period. The relative price effect is neutral, allowing the volume effects to dominate in setting the BoP constraint. The high income elasticities of exports enable growth in the advanced countries to have a multiplier effect on the Vietnamese economy. However, this effect is hindered by a high 'appetite' for imports coming from Asia. We also assess the impact of the current crisis on Vietnam's growth for the period 2011 to 2017.
Evaluating the Costs of Business Cycles in Models of Endogenous Growth
2000
In his famous monograph, Lucas (1987) put forth an argument that the welfare gains from reducing the volatility of aggregate consumption are negligible. Subsequent work that has revisited Lucas' calculation has continued to …nd only small bene…ts from reducing the volatility of consumption, further reinforcing the perception that business cycles don't matter. This paper argues instead that ‡uctuations could a¤ect the growth process, which could have much larger e¤ects than consumption volatility. I present an argument for why stabilization could increase growth without a reduction in current consumption, which could imply substantial welfare e¤ects as Lucas (1987) already observed in his calculation. Empirical evidence and calibration exercises suggest that the welfare e¤ects can be quite substantial, possibly as much as two orders of magnitude greater than Lucas' original estimates.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.